
By Brian Brady, Chief Operations Officer, Gistic Research, Inc.
What if your county doesn’t have the GIS staff to prepare for NG9-1-1?
It’s a familiar problem. Agencies face growing GIS requirements, but many simply don’t have the personnel, experience, or time to do the work themselves.
That doesn’t mean they have to surrender control of their data.
Wayne County, West Virginia, took a different approach: hire the expertise, keep the ownership, and maintain visibility into the work.
And they did it using GIVE.
The problem with traditional GIS outsourcing
For many agencies, outsourcing GIS work has been the only practical option.
The traditional arrangement is straightforward. A county provides its GIS data to a contractor, who performs the work using their own tools and returns updated datasets and reports.
There’s nothing inherently wrong with that approach. But it can create challenges:
- Limited visibility: The county often learns about progress through periodic reports rather than seeing improvements as they’re made.
- Reduced control: The working data may reside in the contractor’s environment.
- Difficult transitions: Changing contractors or bringing work in-house can require considerable effort.
- Knowledge gaps: Important decisions and institutional knowledge may remain with the contractor.
The issue isn’t necessarily the contractor’s expertise or intentions. It’s the separation between the people responsible for the data and the environment where the work gets done.
Wayne County chose a different model
Wayne County needed outside expertise to prepare its GIS data for NG9-1-1, but that didn’t mean the county had to give up control of its data.
Instead, the county established two separate relationships.
- Wayne County subscribed directly to GIVE. The county retained ownership and administrative control of its GIVE environment, including access permissions, GIS datasets, and editing history.
- The county engaged an outside GIS integrator experienced with GIVE. The integrator provided the technical expertise to prepare the county’s GIS data, using GIVE as a shared environment for GIS editing, validation, and progress review.
This arrangement allowed Wayne County to retain direct visibility into its data and the work being performed, without depending exclusively on contractor reports or periodic deliverables.
The county controlled the environment. The integrator supplied the expertise.
That distinction is fundamental to the GIVE integrator model.
What makes a GIVE integrator different?
A GIVE integrator isn’t simply a GIS contractor working independently and delivering updated files at the end of a project.
Gistic works with integrators to help them understand GIVE’s collaborative editing, validation, and data-management capabilities. Integrators can also access Gistic’s technical support team when questions or technical challenges arise.
This arrangement brings together three important elements:
- Technical expertise: An experienced GIS integrator performs the specialized work.
- Direct vendor support: Gistic provides technical assistance with GIVE when needed.
- County control: The county retains ownership and administrative authority over its GIVE environment.
The result is a collaborative model combining specialized GIS expertise, software support, and county oversight, without requiring the county to maintain a full-time GIS staff.
What does this look like in practice?
GIVE’s collaborative environment allows county personnel and outside service providers to work with the same GIS system.
Here’s what that means:
- County-controlled access: The county determines who can access its environment and what each user can do.
- Direct visibility: Authorized county staff can review GIS data and validation results without waiting for contractor reports.
- Accountable editing: GIVE records edits performed within the platform, including who made them and when.
- Map-based collaboration: Bookmarks and messages let users communicate about specific geographic locations and data issues.
- Continuity: The county retains its GIS environment and GIVE editing history even when service-provider arrangements change.
External GIS tools may still have a role in data preparation or specialized processing. The important distinction is that the county’s GIVE environment provides a common place to review, validate, and maintain the resulting NG9-1-1 GIS data.
The county doesn’t have to wait for a monthly progress report to understand where things stand.
Three months to compliance
Wayne County reached NG9-1-1 GIS compliance in approximately three months.
Throughout the effort, GIVE provided the county with direct access to its GIS data and validation results, allowing authorized personnel to review progress as the integrator worked.
Gistic’s role was to support effective use of the platform and assist with technical questions when needed, not to replace the county’s oversight of its contractor.
The integrator used GIVE’s built-in validation and specialized GIS editing capabilities to help identify and resolve data issues.
Rather than depending entirely on lengthy cycles of exporting data, running external checks, reviewing reports, and correcting errors, the integrator could address many issues within the shared GIVE environment.
GIVE’s integrated validation, topology tools, and collaborative workflow helped streamline that process.
But speed wasn’t the only benefit.
When the work was completed, Wayne County still controlled its GIS environment, its data, and the history of changes recorded within GIVE.
That continuity is particularly important for NG9-1-1, where maintaining compliant GIS data is an ongoing responsibility, not a one-time project.
Two counties. Two approaches. One platform.
Earlier this year, I shared the story of Roane County, West Virginia. Roane took an entirely different path.
With no desktop GIS and no prior GIS experience on staff, Roane used GIVE to bring its NG9-1-1 GIS work in-house.
The county achieved full NG9-1-1 address compliance in approximately five months.
Read the companion article: Small County, Big Challenge: How Roane County, WV, Achieved NG911 Compliance Without a Big GIS Team
Wayne County chose to rely on outside GIS expertise. Both approaches demonstrate something important:
An agency shouldn’t have to choose between doing all the work itself and giving up control of its data.
| Roane County | Wayne County | |
|---|---|---|
| Who performs the work? | County personnel | Outside GIS integrator |
| Shared GIS environment | County’s GIVE | County’s GIVE |
| Who controls access? | County | County |
| How can progress be reviewed? | Directly in GIVE | Directly in GIVE |
| Reported time to compliance | Five months (address compliance) | Approximately three months (NG9-1-1 GIS compliance) |
Neither approach is necessarily right for every county. The important thing is having a choice.
What happens when the integrator’s work is finished?
This is where the model becomes especially valuable.
Because the county maintains its own GIVE subscription and environment, it isn’t inherently dependent on a particular contractor to continue using the platform.
As its needs change, the agency can:
- Continue working with its existing integrator.
- Engage a different GIS service provider familiar with GIVE.
- Transition some responsibilities to county staff.
- Adopt a combination of internal and external resources.
The county’s investment in its GIS data, GIVE editing history, and institutional knowledge stays with the county.
That’s a meaningful difference from arrangements in which the contractor controls the working environment. And it gives agencies greater flexibility as their staffing, budgets, and operational requirements evolve.
There’s an advantage for GIS service providers, too
The GIVE integrator model isn’t just beneficial to counties.
GIVE’s multi-jurisdictional capabilities allow integrators to work across multiple client agencies through a single integrator login, while each agency maintains control over its own permissions.
By using GIVE as a common environment for GIS validation, editing, and collaboration, integrators can reduce the effort associated with exchanging datasets and reconciling disconnected working versions.
They can concentrate on the technical work their clients need. They also have access to Gistic’s technical support resources when assistance is required.
The provider’s value doesn’t come from possessing the county’s data. It comes from knowing how to improve it.
That’s a better arrangement for agencies and the GIS professionals who support them.
The takeaway: The choice should belong to the county
Roane County demonstrated that an agency without GIS experience can build internal capability using the right tools.
Wayne County demonstrated that an agency can bring in outside expertise, achieve NG9-1-1 GIS compliance, and retain control of its data throughout the process.
Different staffing models. Different circumstances. The same underlying principle.
Your agency should control its GIS data, regardless of who’s doing the work.
If your agency is weighing the advantages of in-house GIS maintenance against outside services, I’d welcome the conversation.
We can walk through both approaches, discuss your staffing and data requirements, and help determine which model makes the most sense.
Either way, your data stays yours.
#NG911 #GIS #PublicSafety #WestVirginia #LocalGovernment
Brian Brady is Chief Operations Officer at Gistic Research, Inc., developer of GIVE (Geospatial Integration, Validation, and Editing). Since 2005, Gistic has developed collaborative GIS and data-quality solutions for public agencies.
